How we research
Sources
- Korean rankings and awards: Olive Young Korea rankings and awards, Hwahae awards and rankings, Glowpick. We cite results briefly and link to the source; we don't reproduce full ranking tables.
- Korean certifications: whether a product is registered as a functional cosmetic with Korea's Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS), for brightening, wrinkle care or UV protection. We read this from the product information notice Korean retailers are required to show.
- Ingredients and makers: the full ingredient list and manufacturer from the same Korean product information notice, and the ingredient list on the US retailer or brand page.
- Prices: prices we check on Korean and US retailers on the date shown. Korean prices are often sale prices; we show the regular price next to them. Prices change, so treat them as a snapshot.
How we read Korean reviews
For a review breakdown or comparison, we read reviews on one Korean retailer listing (usually Olive Young Korea) in two passes:
- The newest reviews, usually about 50, sorted by date so we aren't only seeing the reviews a site chooses to highlight.
- The lowest-rated reviews that weren't in the first set, usually 10 to 15, so we can see what goes wrong when it goes wrong. If a listing has very few low ratings, we read all of them and say so.
We read at a normal pace and tally how often specific themes come up: hydration, stickiness, irritation, white cast, makeup wear, scent, value and so on. One review can count toward several themes. Every article states:
- how many reviews we read, and from which listing;
- the date range those reviews cover (a listing that gets few new reviews can reach back many months, which mixes seasons);
- how many reviews were too short to count for anything.
When one account posts the same text more than once, we count it once. When a low star rating comes with clearly positive text, we note it rather than counting it as a complaint. A sample of a few dozen reviews shows tendencies, not statistics, and we say so.
We don't copy, translate word for word, screenshot or store reviews, and we never show reviewer names or photos.
Korean version vs US version
The same product name doesn't always mean the same formula. Sunscreens sold in the US must use FDA-approved filters, and brands sometimes renew a product in Korea before the US stock changes. So before we write about a product, we compare the Korean and US ingredient lists. When they differ, we say which version the Korean reviews describe.
Brand claims vs reported experience
Comparison tables put what a brand or retailer says about a product next to what we counted in the reviews we read. When the two disagree, or when reviews simply don't mention a claim, we say so.
What we avoid
- Medical claims, or advice for acne, eczema, rosacea or other skin conditions. See a dermatologist for those.
- Our own star ratings presented as if they were tests. We don't lab-test products, and we don't present our opinion as a measurement.
- Product photos we don't have the rights to. Our images are free stock photos or graphics we make.
Corrections
If a price, ingredient or count is wrong, tell us. We fix it, change the "checked" date on the article, and note what changed at the end of the article when the fix changes a conclusion.
AI assistance
AI tools help us draft, translate our notes and check facts. The sources, the review tallies and the final check are ours.