Compared

Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun vs Round Lab Birch Juice Sunscreen: Closer Than You Think

Korea's two cult sunscreens share a maker and their first 14 ingredients. We read 132 Korean reviews to find the real differences, and what the US versions are.

Hands rubbing in cream by a bright window
Photo: Pixabay
In this guide
  1. At a glance
  2. The twin-formula surprise
  3. What Korean reviewers said
  4. The shared problem: stinging
  5. The US catch: you may not be buying the Korean version

Ask Korean shoppers for a light, no-white-cast sunscreen and two names come up: Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun: Rice + Probiotics (조선미녀 맑은쌀 선크림) and Round Lab Birch Juice Moisturizing Sunscreen (라운드랩 자작나무 수분 선크림). Before reading the reviews, we compared the ingredient lists on Olive Young Korea. That’s where this comparison gets interesting.

14 of 14first listed ingredients that match, in the same order
132Korean Olive Young reviews we read for the two
#1shared complaint in low ratings: stinging

At a glance

Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun Round Lab Birch Juice Sunscreen
SPF / PA (Korea) SPF50+ PA++++ SPF50+ PA++++
Korean “functional cosmetic” Yes Yes
Made by Kolmar Korea Kolmar Korea
UV filters 4 chemical filters (same four) 4 chemical filters (same four)
What’s different Rice and fermented extracts, no added plant oils Birch sap, Scots pine leaf oil, Roman chamomile flower oil
Olive Young Korea ₩15,000 / 50 ml (sale, regular ₩18,000) ₩16,900 / 50 ml + 20 ml cream (sale, regular ₩25,000)
Olive Young Korea rating 4.8 (1,162 reviews*) 4.8 (19,884 reviews*)
At Olive Young US Not listed Sold as a different US formula (“UVlock”)

*Review counts are for the specific listings we read. Olive Young splits reviews across single bottles and promotional sets, so they aren’t a fair popularity comparison. Prices and ratings are from November 21, 2026.

The twin-formula surprise

Both products list the same first 14 ingredients in the same order: water, dibutyl adipate, propanediol, then the UV filter diethylamino hydroxybenzoyl hexyl benzoate (Uvinul A Plus), and so on down to butylene glycol. That includes all four UV filters:

Olive Young’s product notices list Kolmar Korea, one of Korea’s largest contract manufacturers, as the maker of both. Ingredient lists don’t show exact percentages, so we can’t call them the same formula. But the two share a base, and the differences come after it: Beauty of Joseon adds rice extract and several fermented ingredients, while Round Lab adds birch sap and two plant oils.

Why it matters: if one of these didn't work for you because of texture or stinging, the other is likely to feel very similar. If you just want the cheaper one, the core sun protection is built from the same filters.

What Korean reviewers said

For each product, we read the 51 newest reviews and the 15 lowest-rated ones on Olive Young Korea. The newest Round Lab reviews covered just three weeks (October 30 to November 21, 2026). The Beauty of Joseon single-bottle listing gets fewer reviews, so its newest 51 went back to December 2025 and include summer use. One Round Lab account had posted the same review three times. We counted it once.

Beauty of Joseon · 51 recent

Light, lotion-like 17 · Good under makeup 14 · Moist 11

No white cast 10No irritation 9

Round Lab · 51 recent

Moist 23 · Light 14 · No irritation 12

No white cast 11Good under makeup 4

The profiles overlap heavily, which fits a shared base. The differences are in emphasis:

The shared problem: stinging

Stinging was the top complaint in the low ratings for both products.

Complaint (15 lowest-rated each) Beauty of Joseon Round Lab
Stinging or burning (skin or eyes) 7 7
Of those, eyes specifically 5 2
Rash, bumps or breakout 1 3
Doubted the sun protection 1 4
Gets oily or greasy later 3 1
Other (flaking, “just average,” shipping or service) 4 2*

One review can count in more than one row. *Two Round Lab one-star reviews were actually positive in their text, probably a mis-tap on the stars. Two of the Beauty of Joseon eye-sting reviews came from the same person.

In the recent reviews, it went both ways. Three Round Lab users specifically praised it for not stinging their eyes, which their previous sunscreens did, while three mentioned some skin stinging. For Beauty of Joseon, three recent reviewers mentioned stinging or warmth, one around the eyes.

Since both use the same filters and base, it isn’t surprising that they draw the same complaint. Several of the stinging reports came from people who described their skin as sensitive or very sensitive.

Shop smarter: patch-test either one on your jaw for a few days before using it all over. Stop at the bony ridge around your eye rather than applying right up to the lash line.

The US catch: you may not be buying the Korean version

When we searched Olive Young US on November 21, 2026, Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun wasn’t listed. Round Lab was, but as “Birch Juice Moisturizing UVlock” ($24.99 / 50 ml, rated 4.0 from 25 reviews), and its active ingredients are avobenzone 2.7%, homosalate 13.5% and octisalate 4.5%. That’s a completely different set of filters from the Korean version.

That’s because US sunscreens are regulated as over-the-counter drugs, and only FDA-approved filters can be used. None of the four filters in the Korean versions is on that list. The FDA’s first new filter in decades, bemotrizinol, wasn’t approved until 2026 (more on that in our functional cosmetics guide).

So everything Korean reviewers say here, from the texture to the stinging, describes the Korean formulas. A US-formula version may feel and behave differently. It isn’t only sunscreen: the Anua Heartleaf 77 toner on Korean shelves is a newer formula than the US bottle, too.

Which one should you get?

  1. Mostly want it under makeup: Beauty of Joseon drew more "makeup sits well" reviews.
  2. Dry skin, winter: Round Lab drew more moisture praise, and the set adds a mini moisturizer.
  3. Sensitive eyes: neither is a safe bet. Keep both off the eye area and patch-test first.
  4. Prefer no added plant oils: Beauty of Joseon lists none. Round Lab includes pine and chamomile oils.
  5. Shopping in the US: read the active ingredients. "Broad Spectrum SPF" with avobenzone or homosalate means a US formula, not the one Korean reviews describe.

We read publicly visible reviews on Olive Young Korea on November 21, 2026, at normal reading speed, and counted themes by hand. We did not copy, translate or store review text, names or photos. Ingredient lists and manufacturer names are from Olive Young Korea's product information notices on the same day; US details are from Olive Young US. This is a summary of user reports, not medical advice. If a sunscreen stings or causes a rash, stop using it.

FAQ

Are Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun and Round Lab Birch Juice sunscreen the same?

Not identical, but very close in Korea. Both are made by Kolmar Korea, and their first 14 listed ingredients, including all four UV filters, match in the same order. After that they differ: Beauty of Joseon adds rice and fermented extracts, and Round Lab adds birch sap and two plant oils (Scots pine leaf and Roman chamomile). Exact amounts aren't public.

Which one stings less?

We couldn't find a clear winner. Stinging, often around the eyes, was the most common complaint in the low ratings for both. In recent reviews, 3 Round Lab users praised it for not stinging their eyes, while 1 Beauty of Joseon user mentioned eye sting. If your eyes are sensitive, keep either one away from the eye area.

Is the Round Lab sunscreen at Olive Young US the same as in Korea?

No. The US 'Birch Juice Moisturizing UVlock' lists avobenzone, homosalate and octisalate as active ingredients. The Korean version uses four different filters that aren't on the FDA's approved list. Korean reviews describe the Korean version only.

Do these sunscreens leave a white cast?

Korean reviewers rarely saw one. 10 recent Beauty of Joseon reviews and 11 Round Lab reviews (of 51 each) specifically said there was no white cast. Both use chemical (organic) filters, not zinc oxide or titanium dioxide.

Some reviews say the protection is weak. Is that true?

A few low-rated reviews, mostly of Round Lab, doubted the protection after a tan line or a UV-camera video. Reviews can't measure SPF. Both are registered in Korea as SPF50+ PA++++ functional cosmetics. Most real-world sunburn comes from applying too little or not reapplying.

Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun vs Round Lab Birch Juice Sunscreen: Closer Than You Think: key numbers and shopping tips
Save this for your next Olive Young haul

We read Korean rankings and reviews and summarize the patterns in our own words; we don't copy or store reviews. Rankings and prices change often, so check the retailer before you buy. Nothing here is medical advice.